Skip to main content

Vicarious trauma: psychological perspective

In pursuit of telling the story, journalists are sent to traumatic scenes and events to speak to victims and others affected. However, that can expose reporters to vicarious and direct trauma as well.
They're seeing the consequences, the effects.
Reporters can find themselves growing attached to stories being told of trauma, existing as a filter for what is and is not presentable on television. Professionals must consume that media, footage and story details themselves to determine how the story will be told, and will also be exposed to the raw experience of witnesses, victims, criminals and others associated with the story.

Registered Psychologist Annemarie Rued-Fraser says that experiencing disturbance is a human reaction. "If you're not physically present on-site, hearing the story in-depth can in and of itself create disturbance and can create those images--those flashback images from the imagined experience; however if the person is on-site after the trauma has been experienced and they're hearing, they're seeing the consequences, the effects. They're creating a personal connection of sorts with the victims."

Journalists can experience direct trauma through physical and verbal harassment on scene as well as being at risk of violence in extreme circumstances. Isolation and imprisonment abroad are also potential threats posed to journalists, with at least 250 journalists jailed worldwide for four consecutive years as of 2019, with China at the forefront.

Reporters overseas like Kevin Green said that if things went wrong during negotiations in Sudan, he wouldn't get to leave the room the room they were held in. "Sudanese warlords at the time in the Sundanese Peoples' Liberation Army, the SPLA, they would have no hesitation about killing you or anyone else."

PTSD can come from direct exposure or vicarious trauma, and while journalists can exhibit a resilience to the effects of trauma it still remains a prevalent issue long-term for a significant minority (Drevo 2016; Feinstein & Owen, 2012; Morales et al., 2014). The rate of PTSD and psychiatric disorders is low despite high exposure to trauma, with time in the field (Simpson & Boggs, 1999), social support and cognitive factors such as self-worth (Pyevich, et al., 2003) playing a part. Factors that can help defend against PTSD and other issues include emotional control (Nelson, 2011), endurance (Smith et al., 2017), and a sense of purpose (Novak & Davidson, 2013).

Rued-Fraser says that dissociation is an inhibitor of someone with PTSD in the workplace. "When they are completely overwhelmed by the emotional and physical symptoms, they may completely dissociate. They may not be aware of what they're doing. They're no longer present in the present. They're absent in space and time."

Behaviour indicative of PTSD in the workplace includes tardiness, missed deadlines and difficulty concentrating (Drevo, 2016; Nelson, 2011).


Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

About us

The Capstone Group This project is a collaborative effort between three students in the Broadcast News stream at SAIT's RTBN program. Each of us has a bio below. Sean Marks Sean is born and raised Calgarian and grew up around the Broadcast News industry, which sparked his future endeavors’ in pursuing a career as a journalist. He is hoping to get a job as a reporter post-graduation but his dream is to eventually be an anchor or host of a morning/talk show. In April of 2020, Sean will be heading south of Calgary to do his practicum at CTV Lethbridge under the watchful eye of Terry Vogt. His interests include sports, reading, watching movies and TV, and spending time with friends and family. Austin Lee Born and raised on Vancouver Island, Austin Lee grew up listening to CKNW 980 and TSN 1040. The work of Charles Adler, Bill Good and John Shorthouse inspired Austin to pursue a career in broadcasting. When he’s not chasing a story or working on campus, you c
Post a Comment
Read more

Managing conviction: Jeff Little

While reporting on its own can require the ability to distinguish when to take a step back or ask for help, not every journalist can tell right away when a scene has affected them. The responsibility to moderate and keep tabs on the mental state of staff falls on the News Director. We interviewed Jeff Little, News Director at CTV Calgary, about his experiences with hardship both personally in the field as a veteran reporter and what he has noticed watching over staff from a managerial perspective. You need to leave town. You can be gone for days, you can be gone for weeks. Little worked for three years as a national reporter as the correspondent for Alberta, South Saskatchewan and South-Eastern British Columbia before moving to the assignment desk at CTV Calgary. He says the biggest challenge was being away from his family. "I had a young family, and when you're in a national posting, there are occasions where you need to hit the road. You need to leave town. Yo
Post a Comment
Read more

The Humboldt tragedy: Adam MacVicar

Adam   MacVicar  spoke with us regarding his work reporting on the Humboldt Broncos bus crash for Global News Saskatoon, and what it was like for him as one of the first on the scene. This interview marked the first time  MacVicar  spoke on the record about his experience at the scene and the process of engaging the community following the crash.   It was cold. It was very cold.  The crash was South of Nipawin Saskatchewan on April 6, 2018, near 5:00 pm, and  MacVicar  was sent from his post in Saskatoon.  Adam  went with a shooter and was among the initial group to have arrived on the scene beyond first-responders. "When you first get to the scene, separating it wasn't hard because obviously, we had to get something on camera. We had to send it back--we were getting phone calls from our news director: we have to do something. So it was immediately focused on the work. Then when we drove into town, that's when it was starting to get a little--we realized this is defi
Post a Comment
Read more